What the Pandemic Is Telling Us About Science, Politics, and Values
By Daniel Sarewitz,
Slate
| 03. 24. 2020
For the past 30 years, I have tried to make sense of the interactions between science and politics, especially the challenge of making decisions under conditions of uncertainty and disagreement. Why—despite huge and ever-expanding bodies of relevant scientific research—is it so impossible to resolve disagreements around climate change, nuclear energy, mammograms, K–12 public education, chemicals in the environment, genetically modified organisms, nutritional guidelines, trade policy, and on and on? Why, despite all the research and expertise, do the opposing sides of these debates remain fixed in their values and interests, certain in their own version of the facts and immovable in their sense of what should or should not be done?
Thanks to the COVID-19 pandemic, the relation between science and politics is now at the center of the world stage. The novel coronavirus offers up a powerful and extremely clear lesson about the appropriate role of science in helping to guide us toward a better future—a lesson that sharply contradicts standard thinking about science and politics. Above all, we are learning that science’s place in politics is determined not...
Related Articles
By Elizabeth Dias, The New York Times | 08.14.2024
Republicans may be backing away from abortion, but these activists have a strategy, with or without Trump.
The pivot seems clear. The Republican Party of the post-Roe era is sidelining anti-abortion activists. Project 2025, the conservative blueprint with innovative abortion...
By Alison Motluk, Broadview | 08.15.2024
Canada has been slow to end anonymous paternity, but cheap and easy genetic testing makes staying unknown all but impossible.
It was by accident that Jason Tarshis learned the truth about his origins. At 49, he bought a home genetic...
By Sydney Lupkin and Asma Khalid, NPR | 08.15.2024
The White House unveiled the fruits of months of negotiations between the government and pharmaceutical companies: new, lower Medicare prices for 10 blockbuster drugs.
The discounts range from 79% for diabetes drug Januvia to 38% for blood cancer drug Imbruvica...
By Irin Carmon, New York | 09.14.2024
At Tuesday night’s debate, seemingly stung by Kamala Harris’s assertion that IVF treatments have been curtailed “under Donald Trump’s abortion bans,” the former Republican president declared, “I have been a leader on IVF, which is fertilization. The IVF — I...