Regulation: Sell Help not Hope
By Paolo Bianco & Douglas Sipp,
Nature
| 06. 16. 2014
Untitled Document
Modern medicine depends on products that must pass rigorous tests for safety and efficacy before being marketed to patients. Such requirements are in place for drugs and other medical products across the world. Over the past decade, however, some have called to weaken or even undo this key protection.
Think tanks in the United States are using stem cells to promote broader deregulation; these moves are influencing policy in other countries. Some argue that stem-cell products and procedures should not be governed by drug regulatory agencies at all; others want to bypass requirements that treatments must be shown to work before they are sold.
'Free-to-choose' reasoning pits the scientific method against unrestrained market forces. But there is little correlation between business success and efficacy in poorly regulated markets; the billions of dollars in revenue from nutritional supplements and homeopathy bear testament to that.
A loosening of the regulatory strictures would enable companies and practitioners to generate revenue from untested products and procedures. Patients would, in effect, pay to serve as research subjects. Worse, with no requirement to demonstrate...
Related Articles
By Ali Breland, The Atlantic | 08.20.2024
“Joining us now is Steve Sailer, who I find to be incredibly interesting, and one of the most talented noticers,” Charlie Kirk said on his internet show in October. Kirk, the 30-year-old founder of Turning Point USA, a right-wing...
By Megan Agnew, The Times | 09.15.2024
Faith Hartley always wanted two girls — a blonde and a redhead. “I thought, I’ll have one that looks like me,” says Hartley, 35, smoothing her golden hair in the Los Angeles valley home she shares with her husband, Neil...
By Emily R. Klancher Merchant, Los Angeles Review of Books | 08.22.2024
IN THE Operation Varsity Blues scandal of 2019, 50 wealthy parents were charged with trying to get their children into elite universities through fraudulent means. The story dramatically demonstrated the lengths to which some parents will go to ensure their...
By Julia Brown, The Conversation | 08.16.2024
With their primary goal to advance scientific knowledge, most scientists are not trained or incentivized to think through the societal implications of the technologies they are developing. Even in genomic medicine, which is geared toward benefiting future patients, time and...