Paper Raises Hundreds Of Questions About The Integrity Of Stem Cell Research Group
By Larry Husten,
Forbes
| 07. 02. 2013
Serious questions have been raised about the integrity and validity of research performed by a well-established German stem cell research group.
A paper published in the International Journal of Cardiology exhaustively details a multitude of discrepancies and contradictions in papers from the researcher’s group. Further, the revelation of such widespread misconduct may lead to broader disturbing questions about the reliability of scientific publications and the ability of the clinical research system to police itself.
In “Autologous bone marrow-derived stem cell therapy in heart disease: Discrepancies and contradictions,” Darrel Francis and colleagues scrutinize 48 papers from the research group of Bodo-Eckehard Strauer. According to Francis et al, the 48 papers from Strauer’s group contained reports on only 5 actual clinical studies, or “families” of reports, and that duplicate or overlapping reports were common. The paper contains details about more than 200 errors in the papers, including contradictory descriptions of the design, protocol and results of the trials. Francis et al write:
Readers cannot always tell whether a study is randomised versus not, open-controlled or blinded placebo-controlled, or lacking a control group...
Related Articles
By Megan Agnew, The Times | 09.15.2024
Faith Hartley always wanted two girls — a blonde and a redhead. “I thought, I’ll have one that looks like me,” says Hartley, 35, smoothing her golden hair in the Los Angeles valley home she shares with her husband, Neil...
By Julia Brown, The Conversation | 08.16.2024
With their primary goal to advance scientific knowledge, most scientists are not trained or incentivized to think through the societal implications of the technologies they are developing. Even in genomic medicine, which is geared toward benefiting future patients, time and...
By Sophie Zadeh, PET | 09.02.2024
By Staff, Kyodo News | 09.13.2024
Photo by Roméo A. on Unsplash
The Japanese government and people who were forced to undergo sterilization surgeries from the 1950s to the 1970s under a now-defunct eugenics protection law settled their lawsuits on Friday, following a recent ruling by...