[OPINION] Embryo cloning claptrap - is there no limit to public gullibility?
By David van Gend,
The National Forum (Australia)
| 05. 02. 2007
It is one of the unhappier jobs of a doctor to tell a patient she is a victim of false hope. But somebody has to do it, and guide her back to reality and any genuine hope for treatment.
We have read of the Brisbane woman who flew to India to receive injections of "embryonic stem cells" into her spinal injury.
To any medically trained person, this story carries the highest suspicion of fraud. Nowhere in the world has an embryonic stem cell ever been injected into a human, for the very serious reason that they cause tumours when injected into animals. Yet some obscure Indian doctor, whose work is not only inherently absurd - claiming to treat Alzheimer's, which is the very litmus test of stem cell absurdity - and which breaks the cardinal rule of medical research - that experimental treatment must be judged by medical peers before being used on humans - is treated with seriousness by our media.
If only the media could show judgment in what they get excited about. Yes, the first published trial...
Related Articles
By Antonio Regalado, MIT Technology Review | 05.06.2024
It was a cool morning at the beef teaching unit in Gainesville, Florida, and cow number #307 was bucking in her metal cradle as the arm of a student perched on a stool disappeared into her cervix. The arm held...
By Gregory E. Kaebnick, STAT | 09.15.2023
Ian Wilmut, the British scientist behind the first-ever cloning of a mammal, died Sept. 10, leaving behind a twofold legacy. One part is groundbreaking science. Creating Dolly required a combination of genome manipulation and reproductive tools that helped launch what...
Poster for King of Clones (Netflix documentary) via Wikipedia
Back in the early years of this century, the most prominent rogue in biotech was a South Korean scientist named Hwang Woo-Suk. He became one of the best-known scientists in the world, and achieved rock-star status in Korea, when he reported his success using human cloning to create embryonic stem cells. Not long thereafter it was revealed that he had faked his results, triggering a new round of global headlines and...
By Nick Schager, The Daily Beast | 06.23.2023
Poster for King of Clones (Netflix documentary) via Wikipedia
Cloning is, at heart, about the fear of death and the desire to defeat it. Consequently, biologist and researcher Dr. Hwang Woo-suk’s breakthroughs in the field made him not only a...