Human genome editing: From the First to the Third International Summit
By Françoise Baylis,
Impact Ethics
| 03. 22. 2023
photo by Miguel Descart licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0
In early March, I was in London, England for the Third International Summit on Human Genome Editing. It was a welcome occasion to see friends and colleagues and to advance discussion and debate on research involving somatic, germline, and heritable human genome editing.
Somatic human genome editing involves the genetic modification of somatic (nonreproductive) cells. Changes made to these cells are not passed on to subsequent generations. Germline human genome editing involves the genetic modification of reproductive cells (eggs and sperm) or early stage (one-cell) embryos. This research occurs in the lab and when the research is done the modified cells are discarded. Heritable human genome editing involves the transfer of genetically modified reproductive cells to a uterus in the hope of creating genetically modified children.
In this brief commentary, I share my reflections on two of the many successes of the Third International Summit: (1) increased focus on the science, ethics, and governance of somatic human genome editing and (2) public acknowledgment of the need for further discussion and...
Related Articles
Flag of South Africa; design by Frederick Brownell,
image by WikimediaCommons users.
Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
What is the legal status of heritable human genome editing (HHGE)? In 2020, a comprehensive policy analysis by Baylis, Darnovsky, Hasson, and Krahn documented that more than 70 countries and an international treaty prohibit it, and that no country explicitly permits it. Policies in some countries were non-existent, ambiguous, or subject to possible amendment, but the general rule remained, even after one...
By Tamsin Metelerkamp, Daily Maverick | 11.18.2024
The National Health Research Ethics Council (NHREC) has confirmed that heritable human genome editing (HHGE) remains illegal in South Africa, after changes in the latest version of the South African Ethics in Health Research Guidelines sparked concern among researchers that...
By Bernice Lottering, Gene Online | 11.08.2024
South Africa’s updated health-research ethics guidelines, which now include heritable human genome editing, have sparked concern among scientists. The revisions, made in May but only recently gaining attention, outline protocols for modifying genetic material in sperm, eggs, or embryos—changes that...
By Jantina de Vries, EthicsLab | 11.15.2024
The conversation around human heritable genome editing (HHGE) in South Africa is marked by controversy and conflicting interpretations of the law. At the center of this debate lies a team of lawyers based at a South African university, who have...