Editorial: Oversight at Pitt: Whither due diligence?
By Pittsburgh Tribune-Review,
Pittsburgh Tribune-Review
| 04. 26. 2006
A superstar at the University of Pittsburgh was not subjected to commonsensical oversight by his institution.
Gerald Schatten was senior author on a paper describing patient-matched stem cells created through human embryonic cloning.
The research, conducted by Hwang Woo-Suk in South Korea, later was proven an extraordinary fraud.
It is clear Pitt's standards were substandard. The Institutional Review Board took Mr. Schatten at his word that none of the women whose eggs were harvested was identifiable to the researchers. The board, it appeared, did not have jurisdiction.
But it did.
South Korean law requires that families of women who donated eggs would have priority for any resulting treatments. So the researchers must have a way of identifying the donors. Actually, Hwang drove one, a lab assistant, to the hospital for the egg extraction. She later worked in Schatten's Pitt lab.
Strict ethical oversight protects the subjects' privacy and safety. Harvesting eggs is dangerous and questions persist whether the women gave informed consent.
Schatten may have believed all was well until it became impossible to say so with a straight face...
Related Articles
By Matthew Rozsa, Salon | 09.15.2024
When a person with a uterus decides to freeze their eggs, any number of things can go wrong. Ice crystal can form, killing an otherwise viable ovum. A fertilized egg may fail to properly implant, or the egg may...
By Sarah Kliff, The New York Times | 09.09.2024
Image by Stephen Andrews from Unsplash
Yale agreed on Monday to pay dozens of patients who had filed lawsuits claiming that they had endured excruciatingly painful egg retrieval procedures after a nurse at its fertility clinic secretly swapped their anesthesia...
By Ari Schulman, The New York Times | 09.09.2024
There was immediate backlash when Alabama’s Supreme Court ruled in February that embryos created through in vitro fertilization qualified as children under the state’s wrongful death law. But it was a backlash as much from the right as from the...
By Megan Agnew, The Times | 09.15.2024
Faith Hartley always wanted two girls — a blonde and a redhead. “I thought, I’ll have one that looks like me,” says Hartley, 35, smoothing her golden hair in the Los Angeles valley home she shares with her husband, Neil...