Do Not Open the Door
By Marcy Darnovsky,
Southwestern Medical Perspectives
| 12. 04. 2019
Should CRISPR be used to alter the genes and traits of future children and generations? Dozens of nations have considered this prospect and decided that manipulating the human germline should be legally off limits. The U.S. and China have not.
Some gene-editing enthusiasts now want to reopen the question. The answer will affect us all and shape the future. Yet despite the stakes being so high, many discussions of heritable genome editing are distorted by dubious assumptions. The claim that editing human embryos is needed to save babies from inherited disease and could “reduce human suffering in profound and meaningful ways,” for example, is misleading for several reasons.
First is the substantial risk of introducing rather than preventing harm. Editing an embryo’s genes can go wrong in multiple ways, including off-target edits, on-target but inaccurate edits, and a condition called mosaicism that produces a mix of altered and unaltered cells in an embryo – and in the resulting child. No one knows what the health effects of these unintended changes might be, for that child or for future generations.
Second: Safe options...
Related Articles
By Fyodor Urnov, Time | 08.12.2024
After a lifetime in the field of epigenetics, and nearly 20 years after my colleagues and I coined the term “genome editing,” I will be the first to admit that describing the “epigenome”—a marvelous biological process that guides...
By Azeen Ghorayshi and Sarah Kliff, The New York Times | 08.12.2024
An emerging movement against in vitro fertilization is driving some doctors and patients in red states to move or destroy frozen embryos.
The embryo migration is most striking in Alabama, where the State Supreme Court ruled in February that embryos...
By Gemma Conroy, Nature | 06.27.2024
Image by Robina Weermeijer from Unsplash
A molecular-editing tool that’s small enough to be delivered to the brain shuts down the production of proteins that cause prion diseases, a rare but deadly group of neurodegenerative disorders.
The system — known...
By Staff, AP-NORC | 07.12.2024
Image by Dr. Jayesh Amin from Wikimedia Commons licensed under CC by-SA 3.0
Most adults support protecting access to in vitro fertilization, or IVF, a type of fertility treatment where eggs are combined with sperm outside the body in a...