CGS-authored

Osagie Obasogie took notice when he heard about the death of Jolee Mohr, who passed away on July 24 after participating in a gene therapy trial testing a rheumatoid arthritis treatment developed by Seattle-based Targeted Genetics. As director of the project on Bioethics, Law, and Society at the Center for Genetics and Society, a nonprofit organization based in Oakland, California, and as someone who has been studying US oversight of clinical trials, he felt the need to investigate.

So he did, and in mid-August, he published a column in the Seattle Post Intelligencer highlighting possible concerns about the trial's design, in which he noted that "the institutional review board [IRB] charged with ensuring that the trials were conducted ethically is a for-profit enterprise also on Targeted Genetics' payroll." And he wasn't the only one suggesting that might be improper.

There is no hard evidence that Western Institutional Review Board, the "for-profit enterprise" that approved the trial, was remiss in its duties, and the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) points out that IRBs handling clinical trials expected to be used...