A Legal Win for Stem Cell Research, but Case May Not Be Over
By Jocelyn Kaiser,
Science
| 08. 24. 2012
A U.S. appeals court today upheld the legality of federally funded research on human embryonic stem cells (hESCs)—the latest in a string of wins for the National Institutes of Health (NIH) in a 3-year legal battle with groups that for moral reasons want to block the use of these cells. But although hESC researchers can breathe easy for now, the 27-page decision suggests the battle over hESCs may not be quite over.
"It's a clear victory for us. We've very happy with the opinion," says Amy Comstock Rick, an attorney and president of the Coalition for the Advancement of Medical Research, which defends hESC work. However, because the three judges in the appeal of Sherley v. Sebelius issued separate opinions in favor of NIH and used different reasoning, the plaintiffs who filed suit against NIH might have a shot at another review, some legal experts say.
Samuel Casey, an attorney for the plaintiffs, said in a statement: "We are disappointed by the Court of Appeals decision and, given the reasoning in the two concurring opinions, we are evaluating whether and...
Related Articles
Reproductive rights have been a flashpoint in national politics for decades, with the stakes surging after the Supreme Court shredded the right to an abortion. In the current presidential campaign, the battle over abortion has swelled and morphed to encompass in vitro fertilization (IVF), which has now moved rapidly from widely accepted to partisan hot button.
This dramatic shift was highlighted by the February decision of the Alabama Supreme Court that granted personhood rights to frozen IVF embryos, signaling that...
By Gabby Del Valle, The Baffler | 09.17.2024
IT’S A COMMON STORY, banal, even: a child of privilege, an heir apparent, leaves for college to get a good enough education—and maybe have a little fun—before taking over the family business. But the child, away from the nest for...
By Deirdre Walsh , NPR | 09.17.2024
Senate Republicans blocked a Democratic bill to provide a nationwide right to IVF treatments. It was the second time Senate Democrats tried and failed to advance the measure.
Reproductive freedom has remained a central issue in several Senate contests that...
By Ali Breland, The Atlantic | 08.20.2024
“Joining us now is Steve Sailer, who I find to be incredibly interesting, and one of the most talented noticers,” Charlie Kirk said on his internet show in October. Kirk, the 30-year-old founder of Turning Point USA, a right-wing...